
Suzie Owsley
For the second time in two weeks, the City of Eureka was slapped with a lawsuit by a police department employee. This time the Plaintiff is Officer Suzie Owsley, who is also suing Eureka Police Chief Garr Nielsen and Erin McBride, a supervisor at EPD.
Owsley alleges a string of complaints, most of which she first aired in April 2008. Multiple investigations — including one by the Humboldt County Grand Jury — found a similar laundry list of allegations against Nielsen were “without merit.”
The lawsuit is lobbed from the other side of the rift as the one filed by former EPD dispatcher Tawnie Hansen on November 10th. Owsley bases her claims in part on the alleged affair between Hansen and Nielsen — which Hansen and Nielsen both deny. This workplace rumor is also at the heart of Hansen’s lawsuit, and the settlement she won against co-worker DeeDee Wilson in August.
Owsley alleges discrimination based on sex and age but fails to state any facts to support the claim. Her main beef is that she was the victim of retaliation, which she claims happened after she allegedly received a text message from Nielsen. Owsley and other Nielsen haters made much hay with the text, including on the now defunct Above the Law blog presumably run by Wilson. But the anti-Nielsen crowd has yet to form a coherent narrative about the incident.
And here’s some irony: Owsley told the Times-Standard that people should ignore “anonymous blogs.” Yet her story about the text message and the salacious insinuations about same first appeared — anonymously — on Above the Law. Owsley’s lawyer, Bradford Floyd, represented the presumed anonymous blogger Wilson in the Hansen case.
Owsley appears to be one of the “small group of employees” noted by the Humboldt County Grand Jury,” who may never come to terms with some of the changes our municipal leaders are seeking within the Police Department.”
Perhaps the biggest difference between the Hansen and Owsley suits is the events that preceded their filing. Hansen’s suit appears formidable, bolstered by the settlement she already won against Wilson which appears to support her claims.
Owsley, on the other hand, has only multiple investigations which turned up nada, and a Grand Jury report which points the finger at her and those who will testify on her behalf.